The prosecution rested its case against accused killer Randy Roden Friday after calling Dr. Carole Jenny, a pediatrician and child abuse expert, to support the argument that abuse caused the death of 2-year-old Evangelina Wing nearly two years ago.
The toddler was found unresponsive by her mother, Dorothy Wing, and Wing’s live-in boyfriend, Roden Dec. 20, 2014. After a call to 911, the girl was pronounced dead. Her two brothers, 2 and 7 years old at the time, were taken into protective custody.
An autopsy found Evangelina Wing had died of battered child syndrome and blunt force trauma to the head. Her two brothers, 2 and 7 years old at the time, were found badly abused, taken into custody and placed with foster and eventually adoptive parents in California.
Prosecutors have called the case of the worst instances of child abuse in Clatsop County’s history. They charged Roden with aggravated murder, for which he faces death if convicted. Dorothy Wing has been sentenced to more than 15 years in prison, down from a life sentence after she agreed to truthfully testify against Roden earlier this month.
Jenny, who was asked by the prosecution to review the case and testify, described the burns, bites, scars and other injuries found all over Evangelina Wing and her brothers’ bodies. “This was clearly multiple instances of inflicted trauma, of child abuse,” she said during questioning by Deputy District Attorney Ron Brown, head of the prosecution.
Jenny said she has reviewed thousands of cases of child abuse since 1983. “Taking them as a whole, I would put them in the top-three” worst cases.
Roden’s attorney, Conor Huseby, argued that Dorothy Wing caused her daughter’s death through abuse, along with complications from the flesh-eating virus methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus infection, which was found on the children. He unsuccessfully sought to have the case dismissed because signs of the infection were never investigated.
During his cross-examination of Jenny on Friday, Huseby tried to paint her as biased in favor of state prosecutions, pointing to lectures and other trainings she has done for prosecutors, district attorneys and child abuse advocacy groups. Jenny said she gets called more often by prosecutors, but also reviews cases for defenses.
Huseby said Jenny had not reviewed tissue slides from Eva Wing showing the signs of infection and abscesses on her heart, and that she lacks training as a pathologist. “For all you know, her heart could have been riddled with abscesses,” he said.
Jenny admitted that she is not a pathologist and has done no research on the flesh-eating virus methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus infection.
Jenny said she felt comfortable in her diagnoses of child abuse based on clear signs present on Evangelina Wing and her brothers’ bodies, although none of the evidence so far proves who specifically committed each instance of abuse. The prosecution has argued that much of the abuse occurred when the children were under Roden’s care, with Dorothy Wing aiding and abetting by allowing him to babysit.
Before resting the prosecution’s case, Brown played an audio recording of the interview between slain Seaside police officer Jason Goodding and Roden. Goodding, who responded to the Seaside apartment where the toddler was found dead, arrested Roden for aggravated murder, arguing that the injuries to Evangelina Wing happened under his care, and must have been caused by him.